Game Analysis
Lean – CHICAGO (-3) over New England
New England’s offense has come to life in recent weeks, and I rate that attack at 3.1 points better than average when healthy. However, the Patriots will be without both starting guards, Alijah Vera-Tucker and Ben Brown. Losing Brown is not an issue, as Matt Pryor is equally mediocre. However, losing Vera-Tucker, who is a better than average player, is a huge issue because it means that Walter Rouse will be getting his first start.
Rouse played most of the week 3 game against Jacksonville in relief and gave up 3 hurries and a sack in just 24 pass blocking snaps. Rouse has only played 89 pass-rush snaps in his two-year career, but he’s allowed 10 pressures (2 of them sacks), which is a very high 11.2% pressure rate for a guard. Vera-Tucker’s career pressure rate is 5.2%, which is about average (he’s a better run blocker). That 6% difference in pressure rate equates to 2 extra pressures per game, which works out to 1.3 points in expected EPA loss. I’m adjusting a full point, which is a lot for a guard, and I think that adjustment is warranted.
The Patriots have run 54 plays with Rouse on the field this season and they have a -0.22 EPA per play and a 38.9% success rate on those plays, compared to a +0.08 EPA per play and 44.9% success rate when Rouse has not been on the field. Last season the Vikings were -0.37 EPA per play with a 34.5% success rate in 87 plays with Rouse in the game (-0.07 EPA per play and 44.2% success with him on the sideline). That’s a 0.30 EPA per play difference in both seasons, which equates to 18 points over 60 snaps in a game. With such a small sample it is better to use success rates than EPA but this season’s 6% difference in success rate with Rouse on the field equates to just over 7 points per game. With that being the case, I don’t think my 1.0 points adjustment for a guard is unjustified.
Chicago’s defense has been up and down so far this season, but that unit ranks at #15 in the league in EPA per play allowed and #5 in success rate. Their predictive metrics have been 2.6 points per game better than average, but they’ve faced an easy schedule of opposing offenses (Minnesota, Philly and the Jets are more bad than Carolina, Green Bay and Atlanta are good) with average scoring conditions (i.e. weather) than has helped the defense. Overall, Chicago’s defense has been 0.6 points per game better than average but they are a bit worse than average without edge rushers Montez Sweat (suspended) and Dayo Odeyingbo (IR). Those two have a combined pressure rate of 12.4% while the other edge rushers combine for just a 7.4% pressure rate. The Bears’ blitzed more last week to make up for that and it worked better than expected against the Falcons (until the second half).
The Patriots also have a key injury on defense with CB Carlton Davis III out against this week. Christian Gonzalez is the star CB on the team, but Davis is a borderline pro-bowler that has yielded just 5.1 yards per target on 114 targets since he’s been with the Patriots (including the post-season). Charles Woods, who will get the start in his place, has allowed 8.4 ypt in his career (8.1 ypt this season). Last week, with Gonzalez but without Davis, the Patriots allowed Geno Smith to average 8.4 yards per attempt and 6.9 yards per pass play, which are both well above Smith’s norm of 7.4 ypa and 6.0 yppp.
Ben Johnson will scheme away from Gonzalez and pick on the other corners but Caleb Williams’ unwillingness to run the with his bad hamstring (just one real run last week and one QB sneak) costs the Bears 2 points per game based on his career EPA per game on scrambles/runs (excluding kneel downs). Williams’ passing, however, has been bit better so far this season in his 3 games. Williams is completing 72.5% of his passes but his air yards per attempt and yards per completion are down and overall, his 6.5 yards per pass play is just 0.1 yppp higher than it was last season.
The Bears run game also takes a hit with Kyle Monangai out again this week. Monangai averaged 81 yards in his 4 games at 5.4 ypr while D’Andre Swift is averaging a mediocre 4.2 ypr on his 94 runs this season while backup Roschon Johnson has averaged only 3.3 ypr on 22 runs (3.7 ypr in his career), 13 of which he had last week. Not having Monangai is costing the Bears nearly a point per game in production in the run game (more based on this season only).
My ratings favor Chicago by 3.5 points (with 49.3 total points) after adjusting for injuries and I’ll lean with the Bears at -3 -110 or better.
New England Patriots
@
Chicago Bears