Week 1 NFL Best Bet

I have decided to release the following Best Bet early since I think the line is likely to move against me.

Note: The line has moved since I released this play to my subscribers but I still like the Giants at +3 or more and the line may move back to +3.5 so you should consider waiting if your line is currently at +3.


Sunday, September 9

**NEW YORK GIANTS (+3.5 at -115) over Jacksonville Jaguars 

New York had high hopes last season after a successful 11-5 campaign in 2016, but an injury plagued offense and a disappointing defensive performance (after ranking 6th in 2016) led to a disastrous 3-13 season and the firing of head coach Ben McAdoo. Pat Shurmur, who had good success transforming the Minnesota Vikings’ offense last season, is the new head coach and the offense should be much better with Shurmur at the helm.

A lot went wrong for the Giants and QB Eli Manning last season but nothing tops losing his top 3 wide receivers in the same week 5 game. Sterling Shepherd missed a month while Odell Beckham and Brandon Marshall missed the remainder of the season. Injuries on the outside combined with the lack of a real threat in the ground game led to a predictable offense and Derek Carr was the only quarterback afforded less time in the pocket than Manning last year. The good news is the Giants seem to have a solution to these offensive problems for 2018.

New York bolstered their offensive line by adding former Patriots’ starter Nate Solder at left tackle and drafting guard Will Hernandez at 34th overall, which should open up lanes for number 2 overall pick Saquon Barkley up front. First-year running backs are coming fast out of the gates recently with three rookies finishing top 10 in scrimmage yards last season after two rookies finished in the top 10 in that category in 2016. Barkley is the consensus projected top contributor of this year’s class, listed at nearly at a coin-flip (+125) to win Rookie of the Year at Bookmaker, and he will have the benefit of running the same inside zone scheme with Shurmur that he ran so successfully at Penn State. The return of Odell Beckham will also add a spark to New York’s offense and reports out of training camp show he’s taking some snaps in the slot as Shurmur loves to utilize inside receivers with both Adam Thielen and Stefon Diggs of the Vikings finishing in the top 10 last season in yards per route run from the slot. The strategy could prove especially effective versus a Jaguars secondary that couldn’t retain nickelback Aaron Colvin, who ranked 4th last season in yards allowed per slot cover snap.

Last season’s offensive woes directly affected New York’s defense in the field position game with Giants’ opponent drives average start at the 30-yard line (30th in the NFL). New York’s defense dropped from 6th in my 2016 ratings to 24th last year. The Giants’ linebackers were terrible in coverage as they surrendered the 28th most receiving yards to tight ends and the 29th most yards per target to opposing running backs. However, New York seems to have addressed the issue with the signing of LB Alec Ogletree, who finished 10th in yards allowed per cover snap amongst linebackers (min 300 snaps). Top cornerback Janoris Jenkins didn’t get along with the previous coaching staff and played much of last season hurt before opting for surgery in week 13. Jenkins finished 6th in yards allowed per cover snap amongst all cornerbacks in 2016 and new defensive coordinator James Bettcher will want him back at that level after spending three years in Arizona with Patrick Peterson at his disposal. Still, arguably Bettcher’s best asset on this Giants defense is tackle Damon Harrison, who tied for the league lead in 2017 with 45 run stops. New York has solid defensive talent and should improve on that side of the ball.

The success of the 2017 Jaguars was due to their defense, which ranked 2nd in the league in points allowed. The Jacksonville stop unit was led up front by Calais Campbell and earned the nickname Sacksonville with an 8.8% sack rate (2nd). However, much of the damage was against backup quarterbacks and Campbell himself recorded 9 of his 14.5 sacks versus just Houston and Indianapolis. Jacksonville became the first team since the 2013 Seahawks to hold opponents under 5 yards per pass play and they also led the league with a 4.1% interception rate. However, there have been 25 teams in the last 5 seasons to gain more than 100 points in expected points added from interceptions, including the Jaguars last year, and those teams averaged just 73 points added from picks the following season, which is exactly the league average. Furthermore, Jacksonville’s defense experienced a league-leading 19% swing in fumble recovery rate luck from 2016 and is unlikely to be as lucky recovering fumbles this season.

Great defensive seasons are often the result of good fortune in combination with good talent and the correlation of year-to-year points allowed on defense in the NFL is only half of the year-to-year correlation of points scored, which illustrates how much of a team’s defensive performance is out of their control. So, while the Jags’ defense may be just as talented as a season ago, their performance level is very likely to regress towards the mean. Last season, New York was just one of the many examples of drastic fluctuations a defense can experience from one year to the next and the Jaguars’ likely defensive regression is one reason they enter this season a bit overrated.

The Jaguars’ offense was built around RB Leonard Fournette, who had seemingly solid statistics but finished with less than 4 yards per rush, ranking 28th among qualifying running backs. Blake Bortles rated about average last season in our pass efficiency numbers but he benefitted from big leads in many games, which allowed him to attempt the fewest passes since his rookie season. Our quarterback model has Bortles ranked 23rd heading into 2018 and I expect the Jags’ offense to finish in the bottom half of the league.

The Jaguars went 9 years without a winning record before nearly reaching the Super Bowl last season but without any exceptionally dynamic players on offense and a defense in line for some regression, it looks like they will take a step back this year. Meanwhile, the Giants are adding two excellent offensive skill players in Odell Beckham and Saquon Barkley, have a better offensive line, and I expect the defense to bounce back to a level somewhere between their performance of the last two seasons, which would be a significant improvement over 2017’s uninspired effort.

Historically, home field advantage is worth slightly less in week 1 but even after accounting for that this game should be closer to pick (our current numbers favor Jacksonville by just 0.3 points). And, there is some history to suggest that the Giants enter this season underrated. Teams that won 4 or fewer games the previous season, but have won at least 12 games total in the previous two seasons combined, are 28-14-1 ATS in week 1 games. There is some injury risk in releasing this play now but injuries could negatively affect either side and there is more risk in having this line move lower. I’ll take the New York Giants for 2-Stars at +3.5 (-115 or better) and for 1-Star down to +3 at -110 odds.


Dr Bob Sports NFL Best Bet Service

2016 was the first season using the new play-by-play model and my NFL Best Bets the last two seasons are a very profitable 137-101-2 (58%). Prior to 2016 my NFL Best Bets were based on situational analysis and my original math model, which performed very well for many years but offered very little value in later years. My NFL Best Bets were 57.8% from 1987 through 1998 but were just 50.6% from 1999 through 2012, which is when I decided to stop handicapping the NFL until I had a better model.

The new play-by-play model was introduced in 2016 with very good results and an improvement to the model was introduced starting in week 11 of the 2017 season that improved results (21-10-1 on Best Bets the last 10 weeks of the season). Work was done this summer to fine tune the model and the back-tested results were very good – particularly on totals, which have underperformed the last two seasons. I am very excited about the improvement to the play-by-play predictive model and look forward to a profitable 2018 season.

2016-17 NFL Best Bets were 137-101-2 (57.6%)  – 92-48-2 on sides, 44-48 on totals, 1-2 1st-half totals, 0-1 team totals, 0-1 teasers, 0-1 season win totals.

2016-17 NFL Strong Opinions were 92-71-4 (56.4%) – 41-43-3 sides, 43-27-1 totals, 1-0 1st-half totals, 7-1 Super Bowl prop bets.

2017 NFL Best Bets were 37-32-2 (26-22-2 sides, 10-5 totals, 1-2 1st-half totals, 0-1 team totals, 0-1 teasers, 0-1 season win totals) and Strong Opinions were 28-19 (14-13 sides, 7-4 totals, 1-1 1st-half totals, 6-1 Super Bowl prop bets).

View All Dr. Bob Sports Best Bet subscription packages


Dr Bob College Football

My College Football Best Bets are 2038-1679-64 (55%) on a Star Basis for +219.6 Stars Since 1999 (+222.7 Stars on Sides, -32.7 Stars on Totals, and +29.6 Stars on season win totals and futures) and the Strong Opinions are a profitable 637-560-15 (578-498-14 on Sides and 59-62-1 on Totals).

My 2017 College Best Bets were a decent 56-47-2 but I feel my level of handicapping was better than that record. My 101 Best Bets (excluding the 4 season win totals) combined to cover by a total of 229 points, which is an average of +2.3 points, despite my side Best Bets being -9 in fumble margin, which is random and worth about 36 points. A line differential of +2.3 points would normally equate to a win percentage of 56.1% winners, which is the best indicator of my handicapping level in 2016.

View All Dr. Bob Sports Best Bet subscription packages

View information on all Best Bet services

Share this